County Councillors to visit the town over supermarket planning
Thursday, September 10, 2009
“Supermarket Saga Tours” by our on the spot reporter
The Great Day of the Planning Committee meeting in Carmarthen was a bit like one of those historical re-enactments, this time featuring the Grand Old Duke of York. Troops from the opposing sides duly tramped up Castle Hill to the County Hall, and then tramped back down again.
The Cawdor and Lidl applications came up much earlier in the proceedings than expected, possibly because the chairman decided that he wanted to clear the building of the assembled Newcastle Emlyn peasantry as quickly as possible.
At any event, a vote was taken to send the Planning Committee on a day out to Newcastle Emlyn to inspect the Cawdor and Lidl sites. This meant that all discussion was curtailed, and it is unlikely that the meeting will reconvene much before the end of September.
Eifion Bowen, the Head of Planning, noted that opposition to the Cawdor plan was very strong from the public, but he asked members of the Planning Committee to put aside letters they had received from local people, presumably so that the issue can be decided on the merits of the truly bizarre planning report.
Before the meeting passers-by would have noticed a bit of a media scrum going on outside County Hall. The BBC was there, as was the Carmarthen Journal. S4C turned up too late. Interviews were recorded, as usual with 99.9% of the material ending up on the cutting floor.
Afterwards a fairly surreal debate took place on Radio Cymru, with Kevin Davies sounding generally pretty grumpy and fed-up, and the lovely Audrey Baker of Ededa J modelling a little number inherited from Mother Theresa as she movingly described the plight of families with children who were denied the right to shop till they drop in a neighbourhood Tesco store.
Back outside County Hall, Haydn Jones again gave a masterful performance as he waxed lyrical about the beauty and charms of the town – “a town of character” – before adding that progress was sometimes essential. What does it all mean? Why is that man not Prime Minister?
Meanwhile more and more people are scratching their heads as they struggle to make sense of the Planning Report, which now contains an addendum produced by Savills which helpfully tells confused readers that what they have just read is pure nonsense. And they may be right.
For example, the report is based on a study which reckons that £6.4 million currently allegedly spent by people from Newcastle Emlyn at Tesco in Carmarthen will come back to the town. So that means that nobody from Newcastle Emlyn will ever go shopping in Carmarthen again.
For us blokes who have wheeled a trolley round the Tesco superstore as the missus chucks in the goodies, that would be very good news, but something tells me it is too good to be true.
The report also tells us that CK’s and Somerfield would lose half their business to a new supermarket. Not such great news for anyone who works there, perhaps, or indeed for anyone who works in any of the other shops in town facing Armageddon.
Unfortunately we can expect this story to run and run, but let’s all hope that Mr Davies doesn’t get a supermarket for Christmas.
For anyone wishing to come to the next Council meeting, pitchforks and torches will be provided.
Dai Aria












